[dovate.com] » Hawk Mountain & the Curse of Matthias Shambacher

Hawk Mountain & the Curse of Matthias Shambacher

Following is a true ghost story. All photos were taken by myself at the New Bethel Cemetery, unless otherwise noted.

This story takes place in Kempton, PA, a tiny town about 2 hours drive from the city of Philadelphia. The town is nestled at the base of Hawk Mountain. The mountain gets its name from the hundreds of hawks, falcons, eagles and other birds of prey whose various migrations bottleneck over its summit. The Lenni Lennape regarded the mountain as a sacred place and archeologists have uncovered evidence of ritual sites on its peak. European settlers have their own strange relationship with the mountain, most of it intensely dark, even evil.

***

Ancient rumors at Hawk Mountain drift around on decidedly stranger currents than the ones that carry the raptors by each fall. Current residents still whisper old tales of cannibalism and demonic possession. There’s the story of the 10-foot tall man seen roaming through the woods, or a friend’s story recounted to me, of an Indian girl seen standing before him while he gathered firewood. After a few seconds, she vanished into thin air. The more you hear, the more you believe that maybe there is something to all the old rumors—some yarn that ties them all together and some strange, unifying force behind them.
-
At the center of the darkest of these stories is the building that now houses the Bird Sanctuary at Hawk Mountain. In the winter of 1756, an Indian attack left a family of 7 dead, their cabin destroyed. The sole survivor of the massacre, 11-year-old Jacob Gerhardt watched from the woods as his parents and 5 brothers and sisters were brutally murdered. He returned years later to build the stone house that now stands at the site.
-
By the mid-19th century, the building was sold by Gerhardt to the eccentric and reclusive Innkeeper, Matthias Shambacher and his wife Margaret. The Inn was a popular lay-station that gave tired travelers a place to rest before setting out over Pennsylvania’s rugged terrain. Shambacher is regarded as America’s first serial killer. Many of his guests were never seen or heard from again.
-
On his deathbed Shambacher admitted to the murders of 11-14 men (depending on the source) and claimed to have lost count at that 11/14 number. Most disturbingly, Shambacher claimed that the compulsion to kill was “caused by a great evil that lives on the mountain that whispered to him constantly, urging him to murder, even while he slept.” [source]


My first visit to Kempton came in the summertime, just a few years ago. A torrential rain began the moment I crossed the town-line and stopped the moment I left. I had come in search of the New Bethel Church cemetery, home of the gravesite of Matthias Shambacher. Doubling back, I made a second pass through the tiny town. This time, instead of rain, I was tracked by an ominous pick-up truck. Appearing out of nowhere from a private dirt road at the end of a dead end street, the pick-up took up position behind my car and escorted me right out of Kempton. When I crossed the town-line, the truck made a quick U-turn, returning to wherever it was that it came from. Apparently, the residents of Kempton don’t seem to look too kindly on outsiders.

The pick-up kept me out of the town until the following autumn. It would have kept me out for good, had it not been for the story I heard by a campfire one summer night, many years before. The man who told me this story is an upright and honest citizen, not prone to fanciful exaggerations or fabricated tales. He is also a brilliant man with a natural talent for reason unlike anyone I’ve met. He’s a mathematician, and a computer programmer, a man committed entirely to the most rational language in the universe. Beyond that, most of what he told me I’ve heard repeated by others who have shared eerily similar experiences at New Bethel Cemetery.

***

The New Bethel Church cemetery is a beautiful place. Covering a couple of acres in the Pennsylvania countryside, its graves date back more than a century and a half. The town itself hasn’t grown appreciably since the day the first body was put to rest in that mysterious ground. In a world where old cemeteries are rapidly running out of room, more than half of this tiny burial ground still lays in wait. The landscape boasts old groves of native trees offset by small, family owned farms. In the distance, low rolling hills mark the ends of the horizon. At first glance, it’s idyllic.

It was this beauty that brought my friend to the mountainside two weekends a month for a survivalist-training camp. After a couple years of camping in the woods he and his campmates had seen their fair share of strange things: strange lights in the woods; screams in the middle of the night; and plenty of odd characters moving in the shadows. Before long though, any fear they once felt was usurped by a confidence grown by their experience in the woods. So one night after a few drinks, when someone suggested they take the short drive to the base of the mountain to the ‘haunted’ cemetery where the old killer Matthias Shambacher was buried, no one so much as flinched.

It was 10:30 at night when the five young men pulled into the small parking lot of the New Bethel Church. They felt their way around the building, navigating through the darkness towards the cemetery hill. Only one of them knew where to find the unmarked grave of Matthias Shambacher. Making their way to the first row of graves in the oldest part of the cemetery, he found the gap between headstones where Matthias was buried.

The men were comfortable in the cemetery, headstrong, fearless and drunk. Inebriated confidence is a dangerous thing, especially when mixed with late-adolescent machismo. The men, fearless and ignorant, began to try their luck. One of them stepped up and stomped on the grave, shouting profanities at the dead man. Then the one-ups-man-ship began. Someone spat on the ground, laughing and grinding his heel through the dirt and grass. In a few minutes four of the five, (my friend being the only one abstaining) stood spitting, stomping, cursing and taunting the long-dead killer. The defilement escalated to the point of ultimate disrespect, urinating on Matthias Shambacher’s restless, buried corpse.

Now from other stories I’ve heard, this cemetery gives even seasoned ghost hunters a very bad feeling. I’ve been told 5 separate stories, from 5 separate people on 5 separate trips to New Bethel that there’s something about the cemetery that screams “GET OUT OF HERE NOW” to unwanted visitors. It’s the strangest thing, but everyone describes the same feeling. It’s as if someone, or something, doesn’t want them there. Whatever it is, it fills them with an intense fear, forcing them to leave.

When the fear hit my friend and his buddies shortly after the mass desecration of Matthias Shambacher’s grave, it was far worse than anything that any of them had felt before at Hawk Mountain. Their fearless bravado evaporated in an instant. Although no one could define it, something had changed. One moment they felt nothing but their own egos and the next, they felt nothing but fear. Not a word was spoken between them, but there was no question about the message they were receiving. It was restless, angry and powerful. It spoke as clearly as the voice of God spoke to Adam:

GET OUT OF HERE NOW

The fear grew by the second, quickly subsuming their intoxication and driving their quickened footsteps towards the car. There was electricity in the air as they anxiously piled in. Each pore of each of their bodies felt as if invaded by a fine electric charge. The hair on their arms and legs stood on end and a presence other than themselves began to grow between them.

It was at this moment that they turned the key and……… nothing. The car they drove to the cemetery in, the car that they drove to town in, to the hardware store, to the Jersey Shore, to the city, all without any problem at all, was suddenly, inexplicably, dead. Suddenly the realization dawned that they were in the middle of nowhere, miles from camp, sitting in a broken down car, in the dead of the night, trapped in a cemetery more terrifying than anywhere any of them had ever been before. What they didn’t know was that all this was just the beginning.

Frantically, the driver tried the key again. The car sat dead. If they were going to get out of there, they were going to have to do it on their own. Doing his best to force the demons out of his head, the driver enlisted himself and a couple of the others to get out and take a look under the hood. Nothing had actually happened, they tried to tell themselves. It was weird, there was a bad feeling and it was an odd coincidence with the car being dead, but when it was all boiled down, nothing had really happened. No one was hurt physically or in any clear danger. They hadn’t seen or even heard anything unusual. With these thoughts swirling through their minds, they ignored the white-hot energy that pulsed through their bodies like electric fear, and stepped out into the open air.

They tried for 15 minutes to get the car going. Besides the fact that it wouldn’t start, they couldn’t find anything obviously wrong. Their attempts to suppress the fear were failing miserably. (You can try to rationalize with your emotions all you want, but you can’t expect it to do a bit of good.) The feeling of a presence grew heavier with each passing minute and with each futile turn of the ignition. The electric sensation pounded through them like an adrenaline rush that refused to fade. Then out of nowhere and for no reason at all, the car started. Unnerving in itself, they were still partially relieved at the seeming stroke of good fortune. As quickly as they could, they piled back in and pulled into the darkened country road. No sooner had they driven out of the Church driveway than a small animal ran in their path and under their wheel. They thought it was a chipmunk, but what kind of chipmunk was awake in the middle of the night?

Either way it didn’t matter. Although still frightened, there was a sense of relief in being on the road. It was only a few miles back to the familiar safety of the camp. But only a few hundred yards later, a squirrel bolted out into the road. It was too late for them to stop. Less than a mile driven and two animals were dead. The same insidious electric presence from the cemetery began to fill the car. Whatever sense of control they had gained was quickly losing ground to a fear that grew as oppressive as before. A rabbit darted out, running at full speed, as if being chased – hit and killed. Less than a minute later a raccoon appeared – hit dead. The presence was as strong as ever… a possum bounded out from the woods into the path of the car…

Against his better instincts, but seeing little alternative, the driver slowed to an agonizing crawl as animals appeared in the road with bizarre frequency. Animals were nearly pouring out of the woods and onto the road. They swerved to miss them as the ran into the path of their car. Whatever room remained in anyone’s mind to temper the night’s events with rationality had been lost. No doubt remained that whatever was going on was very real. Their fear was real, the presence they felt was real, the dead animals were real and the above all, whatever was controlling the events was real. The only thing they knew for sure was that whatever it was that was pulling the strings had an enormous power to create and manipulate fear in the living. Especially terrifying was the ever-more-likely prospect that the entity responsible was the infuriated spirit of a long-dead backwoods serial killer.

Except for the headlights and for the animals in their path, the road was pitch black and dead empty. The car made it past the last of the farms and onto the mountainside road that led back to camp. Both sides of the winding road were thick with forest. In the distance, their headlights caught glimpses of something up ahead. Now, I swear to God that this story is true. It was recounted to me by a trusted friend and one of the five men who rode that night in this car. Up ahead on that darkened country road, was Matthias Shambacher’s old Inn, the Inn, that saw the Gerhard massacre, the Shambacher murders and even the brutal murder of the priest who lived there after Matthias Shambacher had died.

What they saw, ever more clearly as they approached the Shambacher Inn in the middle of the night, was an ethereal white robed figure wearing a long, grey beard. He stood by the side of the narrow highway at the entrance to the old Inn. In his hand, he held a scythe, or some similar long handled farm instrument as he stood, staring down the car. Seeing the unearthly figure standing ominously at the side of the road, tore away the last bits of self-control the five men desperately clung to. Breaking into a panic, the driver pressed the gas to the floor, passing the terrifying figure with as much speed as the car would allow. They accelerated, 25, 30, 35, 40, until out of the darkness and into the road appeared a deer. By the time the driver hit the brakes they had already hit it, splitting its body, shattering its bone and sending its broken corpse careening back into the darkness. Losing control of the car the driver swerved and skidded, struggling to regain traction and direction. Blood splattered across the hood and stained the windshield. Panic defeated sense as the driver regained control and they drove as fast as the car would carry them back to camp. Come more animals, ethereal figures or even their own death, they didn’t care.

In the end, they made it to their camp, physically unharmed. The car was badly damaged with bits of hair and flesh embedded in the broken grill and headlights. The electric presence vacated their space and their fear began to fade. Emotionally and mentally they suffered far more damage, having learned a valuable lesson about unsettling the dead.

My friend’s story is not unique. I have since learned that tales of Matthias Shambacher and the strange power that his spirit seems to hold are fairly common in that corner of Berks County. The ominous electric presence, the feeling of being watched and even the bearded white figure holding a long-handled farm instrument are all common to ghost stories from Kempton, PA. A quick Internet search will uncover several similar stories.

As terrifying as the stories are, I found myself seeking out the New Bethel cemetery last autumn. During my visit, I didn’t dare disrespect the dead and was careful to leave before sunset. What I found was a strange, beautiful and utterly peaceful cemetery in the Pennsylvania countryside. It was an overwhelmingly calm and quiet day… except for two small details.

The cemetery sits on a hillside. At the top of the hill is a grove of trees. During my visit, hundreds of crows (I believe a group of crows is called a murder) were roosting in those trees. Now I know that crows tend to congregate in groups like this from time to time, but there and then? Normal crow behavior or not, nothing offsets the nerves a bit like a noisy murder of crows. But I soon got used to them and enjoyed the late autumn afternoon in the idyllic countryside. Eventually I got back into the car and started on the trip home. Having left at sunset the road darkened quickly. I recalled my friend’s story and imagined what it must have been like to be in that car. At that moment a spike of energy ran up my spine. It wasn’t a chill; it was more like a jolt of electricity running up my back and to the base of my skull. Startled, something told me to look out the window. Glancing out the passenger side window, I saw a fresh roadside memorial placed in honor to someone killed on that spot. Surrounded by wreaths, written messages and fresh flowers a handmade cross was driven into the ground at the side of the narrow, tree-lined road. At its base, among flowers, notes and colorful adornments was a dead cat. It couldn’t have been more than a few hours old.

The jolt subsided as soon as I passed the memorial. A few hundred yards later I pulled onto the highway and pointed the car back towards the city. It wasn’t much, really just an odd little thing you could easily ignore or write off as coincidence… but when dealing with Kempton, PA, Hawk Mountain and Matthias Shambacher you can never be certain.

24 Comments

  • 1. El Peecho replies at 31st October 2006, 11:06 pm :

    Great story! The legend of Ol’ Mathias is one of the creepiest things I heard in a long time. I know what you mean about the “aura” of the area there. I never been to the cemetery but am planning on visiting in a few weeks. The house and barn area just ooze weirdness. That is if you know the tale behind the structures. Not to mention the little well in the back where the heads wound up.

    Happy Halloween!

    - peecho

  • 2. liz Hornbach replies at 1st November 2006, 4:04 pm :

    hey,

    I am writing a story about shambacher and the local lore, and I came accross your website. I am also in CAP and On ranger staff at Hawk Mountain (as I suspect your friend is/was: you mentioned the 2 weekend a month training). I was wondering the name of your friend. It’s quite possible that I know him too. (although I would have figured I would have heard about this by now). But at any rate, I wanted to talk to your friend to get a few quotes about his exxperience a the cemetary, if possible. Nothing too invasive, just a comment or two to add a send of realness to the story, and bring it beyond more of just a “story”. thanks

    Liz

  • 3. steve weinik replies at 1st November 2006, 10:19 pm :

    I actually left out three parts to the story to keep it more believable. The story was told to me in absolutely serious terms by someone who would not have made it up. This was a close friend of mine. If you don’t believe in ghosts, it’s hard to know what to make of it.

    and Liz, check your email.

  • 4. Sean replies at 18th November 2006, 4:30 am :

    Hey man, just wanted to know I love the story. A friend introduced me to New Bethel Cemetery and I have made many trips up with different groups of friends. You really should make a trip up there during the night. It’s a great experience. I have taken pictures after pictures and gotten tons of orbs. One of my pictures actually had lighting flash across a friend and my owns face. And the funniest thing is, is that the one time when i was scared the most is when a female friend and I both heard “Get the Hell out of here” much like in your story. Its a crazy place and I would love to visit the tavern. If you need any night pictures just send me an email and I would be glad to help you out

  • 5. Joanna replies at 25th November 2006, 6:52 pm :

    ..I went to HMRS (hawk mountain ranger school) for the ES weekend in May of 05. It was awesome. Now after reading the stuff about that guy it sounds creepy as heck

  • 6. Peggy replies at 9th January 2007, 4:39 pm :

    Wow! I had no idea the New Bethel Cemetery was such a hotspot for hauntings. My 8th great grandfather Johann Nicholas Strasser donated the land on which a second New Bethel church was to be built in 1761. The first church on the site actually dates to 1741, meaning that he may have allowed use of the land 20 years before actually legalizing the donation. I have heard that his wife Maria Elizabeth is buried in the cemetery and there is a marker next to her grave that may be Johann’s. (It would be interesting to know if any of the voices heard at night are thiers.) Anyway, I was wondering if anyone had any photos of the cemetery and/or church and perhaps maybe a photo of the grave stone of Maria and the marker next to it. I am writing a family history book and would love to have some photos for my book. The book won’t be published..just a fun thing for me to do for my family. I live in Florida so it’s hard for me to get up there to get the photos myself. I would be glad to give credit in the book to anyone who can get me pictures.

  • 7. steve weinik replies at 9th January 2007, 5:11 pm :

    I know I’ve seen some photos and the photos accompanying this article were
    taken by myself at New Bethel. I’ll dig around for some more too. Haunted or not, the cemetery is really very beautiful.

  • 8. Melissa replies at 31st March 2007, 10:57 pm :

    I went to Hawk mountain last night with my friends to get some silly evp’s and cute pictures. We went to unmarked grave of matthias, as soon as we got there we felt an irky feeling and we all had upset stomachs some even gassy and someone not sure who shouted “you’re a ugly bitch, go to hell.” We were completely offended my one friend even started crying and chanting we are not ugly, this is why were hot, you aint cause you not. She yelled something about him being a mass murderer we must have upset his spirit because she is MIA! someone please help find her.

  • 9. Ramsey replies at 14th May 2007, 1:39 am :

    I’m also a former CAP person who was on staff at Hawk Mtn. I’ve had my own Shambacker experience. There are some scary similarities to the story you told here. I’d love to hear the details you left out b/c I bet they would match what happened to me. I’d also like to know the name of your friends and his companions. There’s a pretty good chance I know them.

  • 10. Jim replies at 18th May 2007, 8:34 pm :

    Hi i went to New Bethel a few times and we actually recorded an evp of a voice saying get out just like it sounded like in the Amityville Horror story movie. We werent sure exactly which grave was Mathis’ but there was one the the initial M. S. were almost carved on. Is this his tombstone? If anyone knows please email me thanks.

  • 11. steve replies at 21st May 2007, 2:13 pm :

    His grave is unmarked. The tombstone was stolen long ago. As far as I know, the gravesite is at the bottom of the hill, next to the road, near the far corner of the graveyard.

  • 12. Linnie replies at 8th June 2007, 10:24 pm :

    Was Matthias’s grave put on the outskirts (sort of unconsecrated ground) as a form of ostracism for his crimes? Seems odd to have buried him there at all, if he was so infamous, even if his family actually wanted him there. Apparently he wasn’t executed— did he die in prison or an asylum, or were his deeds simply never revealed until his deathbed confession?
    And P.S., even if Schumacher WAS a murderer and was actually buried in that spot, what your buddy and his buddies did in that cemetery was TOTALLY REPREHENSIBLE. They DESERVED the scares they got, even if, as I believe, there likely was nothing supernatural about the circumstances. I have SUCH a desire to smack people who desecrate cemeteries in any way, shape or form. Who the heck knows, maybe that was REALLY the unmarked grave of an innocent, hapless slave or poor person who couldn’t afford a headstone. Jerky boys they were, all of them.

  • 13. Laura replies at 26th June 2007, 7:59 pm :

    ok i wanna get a couple things straight…ive lived near kempot almost my whole life..and ive been to hawk mountain a couple times and new bethel cemetary many many times..all of bing during the night..and i have never seen anythin like that at all. not even close to it..the part about the car not starting i believe cause that happened to us but the animals and the figure aint very believable..another thing is your friends are assholes how can you disrespect a person like that weather their dead or alive it dont matter..personally id like to kick them in the face..and about the unmarked grave..he had a tombstone at one time but some people decided to steal it because of who he was…get your facts straight before you write something and make sure its believable

  • 14. Steven replies at 17th July 2007, 12:32 pm :

    I went to Hawk Mtn Ranger School, nothing happened. the story is still entertaining and creepy. nothing happened, not even during the three days we spent away from base.

  • 15. Mike replies at 5th August 2007, 9:03 pm :

    I always get a good laugh when I hear Hawk mountain ghost stories. For all 43 yrs of my life I have hiked/biked/hunted the hawk mountain area and the whole section of the AT/Game lands in that area. Number of ghosts ….Zero. If I had a dollar for every night I spent in the woods around that area I would be rich. City boys scare so easy…LOL

  • 16. Linda replies at 29th August 2007, 4:35 pm :

    I was chilled by this story, I believe it, I plan to visit Hawk Mountain myself one day. Maybe something will happen, maybe it won’t. Spirits come and go. They don’t always make themselves known to everyone. Sometimes more than one person experiences the same thing - sometimes only one person does. Sometimes in a group only a select few. Depends on the spirit, depends on the person, depends on the conditions. I am often (but not always) sensitive to these things. On one occasion, I can remember my boyfriend and my son’s friend (age 13) experiencing a feeling when they entered a room in an old abandoned house we were exploring. I, on the other hand, did not (and I am usually the one who does). I knew what they were feeling was real, even though I was not feeling it myself. I just wasn’t connected with those particular spirits on that particular day. Some people will go their whole lives and never experience anything out of the ordinary (or don’t recognize it, or outright deny it). My point here is in support of this story.

  • 17. Samantha replies at 18th October 2007, 6:04 pm :

    ive been there before many many times. My boyfriend lives about 3 mintues away. The picture make the cemetary look scarier than it really is but it is eerie. It really is a beautiful site but i let the stories get the best of me and i think its scarier that beautiful.

  • 18. Casca replies at 21st October 2007, 4:06 am :

    Friend and I met the author of ‘ghost stories of the lehigh valley’, Charles J. Adams, at East Stroudsburg University last weekend and he spoke about Hawk Mountain and its ghosts. We took a motorcycle ride there to the church and cemetery from Allentown tonight shortly after midnight. We stayed about an hour, found the grave, walked all over the cemetery. Did not see, hear, or feel any ghostly presence whatsoever. I even yelled a bit, trying to provoke some sort of reaction. Only thing amazing about it was how clear the sky was. Supposed to be meteor showers. Saw a few. That’s about it. No ghosts, no fear, no nothing.

  • 19. steve weinik replies at 21st October 2007, 9:53 am :

    That’s too bad? I’m not sure which experience I’d want to have.

  • 20. Casca replies at 21st October 2007, 10:46 pm :

    noo…not bad at all. Was hoping for something scary to happen. We did have a cat cross our path when we left there. Left out of the church lot, left again onto Old Philly Pike. Not a black one, unfortunately. Got home at 3 a.m. Well worth the trip tho’. We think we found the right grave. The tombstone is gone, but is there the foundation from where it was broken off still there?

  • 21. Christian replies at 1st November 2007, 1:44 am :

    I was there about 12 years ago around midnight, never went to the bottom of the hit hill near the grave yard but we did stop at the top near the entrance to the sceenic overlooks… there were probably close to 10 of us there in 3 cars… myself and 2 other friends (one of which was my girlfriend’s brother). Every one was screaming trying to provoke the spirits and they were successful. Myself and my girlfriend’s brother seen 2 sets of red eyes coming towards us through the woods and an unbelievable fear over came us. Since then I haven’t been back there after midnight but I would love to just to see if it would happen again

  • 22. Christian replies at 1st November 2007, 1:46 am :

    Oh and there is more to the grave yard and Mathias’ gave then what was said in this story.. I have heard stories of water running up, yes I said UP his grave stone among other stories.

  • 23. Tim replies at 6th May 2008, 9:49 pm :

    Very good story with great storytelling. I hike the AT around there all the time and camp overnight by myself, but I’ll admit some of the yarns I’ve been reading have me a little spooked.

  • 24. kelly replies at 16th August 2008, 1:06 pm :

    I totally agree with what linnie said … ppl that disrespect peoples graves reguardless of who they were is wrong they should be ashammed of themselves I’m glad they were scared out of there minds weather it had to do with ghosts or not And for the haunted part of hawk mountain Ive lived in that area for 30 years and some things are true and some r a stretch from the truth ive camped up there many times and have seen few things but nothing to the extent of some of the stuff these other people r saying i am also cherokee indian and i feel i have a very good connection with spirits and ive never had any of these talltale experiences i hope to one day though i think its very neat to have that type of experience

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <strong>